Skip to content

Have We Lost The Future?

55
Share

Have We Lost The Future?

Home / Have We Lost The Future?
Books Science Fiction

Have We Lost The Future?

By

Published on July 18, 2012

55
Share

This isn’t a proper writeup of the Readercon panel of this name that I was on this weekend, it’s more a series of reflections of things around it. The description of the panel was:

Where science fiction once looked to the future as the setting for speculation, nowadays the focus seems to be on alternate pasts, fantasy worlds, or consciously “retro” futures. We’re no longer showing the way to what things might be like. We discuss whether this is connected to the general fear of decline and decay in the English-language world—or has science fiction simply run out of ideas?

Jim Cambias, the moderator and proposer, had stats from recent Hugo nominee lists compared to older ones that did show a decline in actual future-based SF. I think this combines with futures we can’t get to from here—steampunk, John Barnes’s The Sky So Big and Black, Ken MacLeod’s The Execution Channel, Stirling’s Lords of Creation series, etc.—to reflect an actual problem in current SF.

But of course, it’s more interesting than that.

It’s possible to exaggerate how optimistic and positive and future-looking SF was in the past. In fact, when you look at them, often the worlds were really pretty horrible. I’ve written about the dystopic Earths of Heinlein’s juveniles, overcrowded, guild-ridden, short of food, in a perpetual nuclear deadlock… but of course the point was to leave. The message was to get into the new frontier of space, where a man could stretch his legs and there was a looseness about things.

Steven Popkes suggested that it was the technical difficulty of space travel in reality and the emptiness of the solar system combined with the excellence of computer graphics that had led to a withdrawal from a space future. (This may be true for movies, but how much of a budget for CGI did Poul Anderson need?) Paul Park thought on the other hand we’d lost the will to the future. There was some hand-wringing about U.S. decline.

I think there used to be a science fiction consensus future in which we’d expand slowly out from Earth and colonize the moon and Mars and the Belt, which would be full of independent-minded asteroid miners, and outward to the stars, at first slower and then faster than light, meeting aliens and ending with galactic empires. The Cold War, naturally, would still be going on in the twenty-sixth century, and if not there would be some Cold War analog dividing humanity into big ideological blocs. Lots of the SF written between 1930 and 1989 fit into this rough future outline. It didn’t belong to anyone. Everyone could set things within this rough future and make their own specific corner of it shine. Details differed, but this was The Future we were headed for, this was almost destiny. Leviathan Wakes is set in this future, but I can’t think of anything else written this century that is.

I remember reading Bruce Sterling’s short story “We See Things Differently” in 1991 in a Dozois’s Best SF, and having the same feeling I had when the Berlin Wall came down. This wasn’t the future I expected to be living in. We were off track for that SF consensus future. And we sent robots out to explore the solar system for us, and there weren’t any Martians, and it seemed as if maybe space wasn’t the U.S. frontier with a different atmosphere.

When I’m writing here about older SF, I often laugh at their hilarious huge clunky computers and add “But where is my moonbase?”

During the panel I mentioned Arthur C. Clarke’s examplary little boy who would read SF and say “When I grow up, I’m going to the moon.” I was that little boy, I said, and of course everyone laughed. There are ways in which this future, the one we’re living in, is a whole lot better than what we imagined. It has women in it, and it has women who are not just trophies and are not manipulating their way around because they have no power. This future has women with agency. It has men and women who aren’t white and who aren’t sitting at the back of the bus or busy passing. It has gay people out of the closet, it has transgender people, and all over the place, not only in the worlds of Samuel Delany. Beyond that, unimaginably shaping the future we couldn’t imagine getting, it has the internet.

So this is my question. If, when you were twelve, somebody had given you a straight choice for 2012, which would you have chosen, moonbase or internet? (Let’s assume they could have explained fully what the internet was and how it would affect your life.) Moonbase, or internet? It really isn’t easy.

Because the future’s still there. The moon’s there and people have walked on it, the stars are there and extra-solar planets, and I still believe we’ll get there. We won’t get there the way we imagined, but the future is never the way you can imagine. After the panel, I was talking to a group of four fifteen year friends who had been in the back of the room and asked interesting questions. They were local, they had come to the con on their own after one of them had come last year. They didn’t think that we’d lost the future, far from it. They thought it was just that we had too limited an idea of what the future could be.

We make our own futures—it doesn’t have to be a binary choice, we have the internet and we can keep working towards a moonbase too.

As for SF—I don’t think it has run out of ideas. I do think it’s a betrayal of the future to write things set in futures we can’t get to. And I always want more books with spaceships and aliens. But I recently read M.J. Locke’s Up Against It, which is set in space in our future and is wonderful and just the sort of thing to give me faith that there’s a lot of juice in the genre yet. And there’s plenty of future coming for it to work out.


Jo Walton is a science fiction and fantasy writer. She’s published two poetry collections and nine novels, most recently the Nebula winning and Hugo nominated Among Others. She reads a lot, and blogs about it here regularly. She comes from Wales but lives in Montreal where the food and books are more varied.

About the Author

Jo Walton

Author

Jo Walton is the author of fifteen novels, including the Hugo and Nebula award winning Among Others two essay collections, a collection of short stories, and several poetry collections. She has a new essay collection Trace Elements, with Ada Palmer, coming soon. She has a Patreon (patreon.com/bluejo) for her poetry, and the fact that people support it constantly restores her faith in human nature. She lives in Montreal, Canada, and Florence, Italy, reads a lot, and blogs about it here. It sometimes worries her that this is so exactly what she wanted to do when she grew up.
Learn More About Jo
Subscribe
Notify of
Avatar


55 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Avatar
Joey Geko
12 years ago

I just read through it, so it’s on my mind, but where does Scalzi’s ‘Old Man’s War’ fall for you? It seemed to present your “old style” sci-fi. Galactic Empire. Vast array of alien life. I think there was a moon base. ;)
It has a flavor of the dystopic, with the sequestered earth and totalitarian Colonial govt.
Thoughts?

Avatar
James Davis Nicoll
12 years ago

Leviathan Wakes is set in this future, but I can’t think of anything else written this century that is.

Aside from Pirates of Mars, The Quiet War, The Moon Maze Game, The Highest Frontier, [1] The Next Continent, The Ouroboros Wave, Platinum Moon, Leviathan Wakes (which you mentioned), Caliban’s War, Back to the Moon, The Quantum Thief, Gardens of the Sun, Up Against It, Usurper of the Sun, Winning Mars, Threshold, Blue Remembered Earth and 2312 I cannot think of any either. Well, unless anime counts and then you have stuff like Planetes and Rocket Girls [2].

Wait, there was that stinker set on Venus. It belongs here too but I hesitate to mention it lest that cause someone to try to read it.

1: Yes, Rocket Girls and Rocket Girls: The Last Planet usually go here but they were first published in 1996 in Japan.

2: The anime is from 2007.

Avatar
James Davis Nicoll
12 years ago

Wait, forgot David J. Williams’ dystopic Autumn Rain trilogy. Yes, THAT David J. Williams:

http://autumnrain2110.com/blog/2009/06/19/incident-at-lasfs-or-i-get-in-a-steel-cage-with-jerry-pournelle/

(OK, now someone else comment so if I keep thinking of stuff to mention this doesn’t turn into one of those five comments in a row by James articles)

stevenhalter
12 years ago

So, the future seems to not be so much lost as momentarily misplaced. Thanks James for collecting those into a list.

Avatar
12 years ago

Is the future we used to see, with humanity out in our solar system, a victim of the fact there’s no money in it?

“I want to be an aerospace engineer!”
“That’s nice, son, but you’ll never make any real money that way. Get a consulting job with a financial firm, that’s a good boy.”

Are we getting the future we deserve because of where we are stacking the monitary rewards our society provides?

Avatar
SarahPi
12 years ago

I was at that panel!
Somebody made an interesting comment about the fact that Heinlein and Clarke were free to imagine certain things because restrictions hadn’t been placed yet. The example suggested was that they could write about space travel without worrying about the dangers of extended exposure to radiation, since that had not yet been proven. We were still x-raying children’s feet in shoe stores for fun.

I think all of this can be intimidating to young writers. You can’t create an alien without its viability being critiqued. You have to have a scientifically viable way to get your characters into space before you can write the story you set out to write. It’s easier to write a parallel universe or an alternate future than to speculate on possible futures, and you open yourself up to far less criticism.

Avatar
James Davis Nicoll
12 years ago

UAI is in what I have just now without any consideration at all decided to call the Modified Concensus Future: instead of the inevitable Troubles of the 21st century being caused by a lack of resources (Bova’s Millennium), overpopulation (Imperial Earth‘s backstory), or atomigeddon (Worlds, the Gaea Trilogy), it’s caused by climate change* (also seen as a significant background detail in The Highest Frontier, the McAuley drearfests and in the more upbeat Blue Remembered Earth and Bowl of Heaven). Otherwise the set pieces are all pretty familar and with parallels with earlier concensus future SF.

that’s 17 in 12 years

It’s more like 17 in six or fewer years: there was a long desert when very few interplanetary adventure SF novels were published in America. Even so, note that a good chunk of the good I mention are translated from Japan, not l’anglosphere.

One thing I think is habitually overlooked by most authors – yes, yes, Mr. Stross, I see you waving at the back – is the likelyhood space exploitation will be dominated by machines in much the same way space exploration is dominated by machines. Planetary Resources, Inc., for example, shows a robot to human ratio you would not see in SF. How to make a solar system seething with machines narratively interesting is a task I leave for the writers.

* Apparently I come off as a climate change denier when I point out that crap books like The Windup Girl are still crap books even if they have climate change in them so a clarification: I am not a climate change denier.

Avatar
seth e.
12 years ago

How to make a solar system seething with machines narratively interesting is a task I leave for the writers.

Apropos of nothing in particular, I loved The Runaway Robot by Lester Del Rey when I was very small. The little boy character was boring, but I thought the first-person robot narrator was great. I don’t see why you couldn’t have more of those.

stevenhalter
12 years ago

James@8:

It’s more like 17 in six or fewer years

Yes, that’s what I meant by momentarily lost. I haven’t looked, but my reading experience was that the “books in space” seemed to become vanishingly small in number, but that they seem to be reappearing.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined