Skip to content

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: “Heart of Steel: Part 1 & 2”

8
Share

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: “Heart of Steel: Part 1 & 2”

Home / Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: “Heart of Steel: Part 1 & 2”
Blog

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: “Heart of Steel: Part 1 & 2”

By

Published on February 5, 2013

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2
8
Share
Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

“Heart of Steel, Part 1”
Written by Brynne Stephens
Directed by Kevin Altieri
Episode #038
Music Composed by Richard Bonskill, Tamara Kline
Animation Services by Sunrise
Original Airdate—November 16th, 1992

Plot: When a robotic briefcase robs Wayne Tech, Batman follows the trail to Bruce Wayne’s old mentor Karl Rossum, Rossum’s bombshell of an assistant, Randa Duane, and Rossum’s super computer, HARDAC. Meanwhile, Barbara Gordon is home from college and she notices her father Commissioner Gordon has suddenly gone very cold….

“Heart of Steel” is not shy about displaying its influences. HARDAC is every supercomputer Kirk ever faced on Star Trek: TOS, with the single red eye of HAL 9000 and a voice like the Superman arch villain Brainiac. Meanwhile, the duplicate robots are a little bit Terminator and a lot Blade Runner, the producers going to so far as casting professional sad sack William Sanderson as the robots’ maker, Karl Rossum. Rossum’s company shares a name with the Transformers’ home planet, Cybertron. And Rossum’s name and Randa’s license plate are direct references to R.U.R., the Czech play that was the original robot revolution story, and the origin of the English word “robot.”

Even after the mind-reading machine and the man-bat, this is the most science fictional episode so far. “Heart of Steel” drops us into the thick of it with one of the most out-there set pieces of the series, Batman getting his ass kicked by a briefcase. And while Batman is surprised by a piece of luggage with Doctor Octopus arms, his mind isn’t exactly blown, and he calmly catches up with the machine with the glider he stores on top of Wayne Tower. Batman just accepts that computers that can think for themselves and robots that can pass for human are the logical next steps in technology. After all, there’s a super computer and robot arms in the Batcave too.

(Small note: Bruce Wayne is locked away by security during the theft, which he escapes from through the secret door he of course also has. Did no one notice Bruce Wayne wasn’t there after the theft was over?)

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

Boy can the robots pass for human. Randa Duane is the most sexualized woman in the series since Poison Ivy. Modeled on Marilyn Monroe, Randa is a head-turning siren with her own noirish sexy saxophone theme who wears form fitting suits or even more form fitting lab gear. Implicitly, Rossum built Randa to replace his lost daughter. I wonder if in the first draft she replaced Rossum’s wife. Certainly Bruce Wayne seems taken with her. Even if Bruce’s (hilariously fake) smarm is just a facade while he interrogates her about the robbery, the first thing Bruce does upon meeting Randa is reach for her breast.

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Hearts of Steel, Part 1 & 2

HARDAC is the villain of the piece, and a pretty straight forward one, but in a very real way he’s just a manifestation of Karl Rossum’s inner struggle. Rossum is another dark reflection of Bruce Wayne, someone who has suffered a tragic loss of a family member and taken to extreme methods to make sure it never happens again. But rather than focus on revenge, as Wayne and many of his villains have, Rossum has gone deeper and blamed human fallibility. He’s trying to erase human error.

Let it be known that we at Tor.com are huge fans of William Sanderson, and he’s amazing here. A veneer of pathetic, insincere affability covering a bitter and lonely life, while also having an ounce of hope. Even before he admits it, Rossum must know what he’s doing is wrong. Why else show Bruce Wayne HARDAC before Wayne has any reason to suspect him? Rossum wants to be caught. He wants Batman to stop him.

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

“Heart of Steel” also introduces Barbara Gordon, the future Batgirl, who will be a very important character later, especially in The New Batman Adventures and Batman Beyond. As with Two-Face, the series writers introduce Barbara in her civilian identity in episodes before she becomes a super-character, so that when she eventually does don the cape and cowl, Commissioner Gordon’s adult daughter would not appear out of nowhere.

Not that she does much in this half of the two-parter. Mostly she’s just introduced, though we get some good character moments. Bruce Wayne’s known her since she was 15 (and boy is that going to get creepy later) and Gordon is uncomfortable with his daughter growing up, bringing her favorite teddy bear Woobie with him to the airport and making sure Barbara has it at all times. Gordon and his daughter spending an evening at home when there’s suddenly a sinister knock at the door homages The Killing Joke, only this time it’s James Gordon who opens the door and is shot for his troubles. And Barbara knows something is wrong the moment her father backhands Woobie off the couch.

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

It’s really in the second half where Barbara shines, and also in the second half where this episode goes bug nuts insane.

 

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

“Heart of Steel, Part 2”
Written by Brynne Stephens
Directed by Kevin Altieri
Episode #044
Music Composed by Carl Johnson
Animation Services by Sunrise
Original Airdate—November 17th, 1992

Plot: HARDAC’s plan to replace the powerful of Gotham with robot duplicates continues as Mayor Hill, Detective Bullock, and Bruce Wayne are targeted. As Batman fights for his life, Barbara Gordon conducts an investigation of her own.

Like “Robin’s Reckoning,” this two-parter has the same writer and director for both episodes, and this time even the same animation studio, so there’s no drop in quality at all. This really does feel like one long episode, including a joke that’s only funny if you watch both episodes. In Part 1, Alfred comments on the mangled bat-glider “I do wish you wouldn’t play so roughly with your toys, sir.” And when HARDAC turns the Batcomputer against Batman, Alfred responds “I do wish your toys wouldn’t play so roughly with you, sir.”

The biggest difference between the episodes is the Part 2 is pants-wettingly terrifying. Maybe I find body snatcher stories, where loved ones are replaced by unfeeling clones, particularly sickening, but Kevin Altieri bring his A-Game to the robot duplicates crab-walking around elevator shafts, red glowing eyes, torn off faces, and an unfeeling machine with a giant fucking laser burning up his creator. I find myself losing my shit.

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

I cannot stress enough how nightmare inducing Cybertron is. Everything is automated, down to the trash cans, and they are all trying to kill humanity. Nothing is what it seems. Headlights of a truck turn out to be two robots. Loved ones start flipping around with metal coming out of their face. People keep exploding. And the whole time, HARDAC is promising to take over all of Gotham, then all of the world.

Holy Crap! Holy Shit! Holy Fuck!

The opening must be particularly gut wrenching for Batman himself. The Batcave, after all, is where Bruce goes to feel safe, and HARDAC has not only invaded, but turned the cave against him. That’s Ra’s Al Ghul level villainy. As with Kyodai Ken, I wonder why HARDAC was never brought to the comics or other media. Is it because, when his light’s not on, you can see Rossum drew a smiley face on him?

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2
Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Parts 1 & 2

In direct contrast to how terrifying the villain is, Barbara Gordon really shines. This is, after all, the episode that argues that she should become Batgirl. Melissa Gilbert nails a character who is absolutely out of her depth, dealing with a literally impossible situation, but determined to do whatever she can to save her father. She’s brave, strong, clever, and willing to pull on Batman’s cape to get what she wants. After saving her father, she goes back to save Batman (mission creep hits Gotham again). I can’t tell if Barbara using her foundation powder to find finger prints and vanity mirror to reflect a laser is clever or stupid (she fights crime with make-up ‘cause she’s a girl, get it?). She also looks appropriately horrified when she thinks she helped kill Harvey Bullock, before learning it was actually a Robo-Bullock (did Batman know it was a Harvey-Bot? Because he does not hesitate to throw him into the Batsignal).

My one complaint about the episode is that the Commissioner Gordon-Bot is so obviously out of character that Barbara doesn’t get to prove that she’s a good detective. She says “it’s not as obvious as bolts on his neck,” (referencing another influence) but anyone could see that Gordon’s personality had been replaced. It’s weird, because all of the other duplicates impersonate their targets almost perfectly, if more dickishly (or, in Bullock’s case, just a tad more dickishly). Randa Duane keeps joking and flirting with Bruce long after she’s revealed to be a robot. Why is the Gordon-bot so badly programmed?

Batman: The Animated Series Rewatch: Heart of Steel, Part 1 & 2

This episode ends with a note of future adventures, as Barbara comments “I sort of enjoyed it,” to a puckish musical sting and a suspicious look from her father. Clearly she’s coming back. But HARDAC is coming back too. Randa Duane, after all, discovers that Bruce Wayne was Batman, and HARDAC only replies “This data may be useful later” and does nothing with that information. This episode. Consider “this data” to be Chekov’s Gun. It’s going to go off with a bang a few months from now….


Steven Padnick is a freelance writer and editor. By day. You can find more of his writing and funny pictures at padnick.tumblr.com.

About the Author

Steven Padnick

Author

Steven Padnick is a freelance writer and editor. By day. You can find more of his writing and funny pictures at padnick.tumblr.com.
Learn More About Steven
Subscribe
Notify of
Avatar


8 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Avatar
12 years ago

I totally agree, but I have a feeling I will be in the minority. It’s not that him falling in love with the holographical representation is unforgiveable – I think many people have preconcieved notions of people that we fall for (although I did also find it a bit creepy). But the fact that, once faced with her feelings towards it he then throws it in her face and makes it about HER behavior!! And while she was certainly blunt, she was never mean. And even if she was, that’s beside the point. After the last episode with somebody usign sex-as-blackmail to help somebody escaped (we watched these two back to back) I was squicked out.

I really would have liked to see more consequences, or at least him realizing exactly why what he did was creepy and why she felt offended by it, even if his motives weren’t as bad as she thought they were, and he did ultimately realize he was just seeing what he wanted to see.

As for the other subplot, I liked it, but it made me really sad, heh. Especially because they never rule out the idea that these could be sentient (although I suppose Deanna would have said something). But my son was weaned a few months ago (sooner than I wanted to) so it kind of struck a cord, ha!

Avatar
12 years ago

Oh, and my husband had fun imagining what the conversation with Leah and her husband at the end of the episode was REALLY like. “OMG, there is this creepy engineer on this ship, I can’t wait to get home!”

Avatar
12 years ago

ugh, I just went and re-read the Booby Trap episode, and I forgot they kissed. CREEPY!!!!

Avatar
12 years ago

Lisamarie@2, your comment makes me want to go write a fanfic about that conversation.

“The engineer on this ship is a real sicko. And I just had to pretend to be friends with him!”

“That’s awful, honey. Perhaps when you get home I can give you a nice backrub…”

Avatar
Bruuuuce
12 years ago

Nuts; I just lost a private bet with myself (I had the over/under for the word “creepy” or variations on it at ten, and you only managed nine in the post :-)

I can’t see how La Forge didn’t wind up facing charges for his holosimulation once Brahms discovered it. He’d probably have been exonerated (because it DID save the Enterprise), but in a paramilitary organization, that bit of creepitude deserves at least an administrative hearing. Compounded by his childish behavior and projection, I’d say he’s inordinately fortunate to have retained his commission, much less his post as Chief Officer of the flagship.

Avatar
12 years ago

Gotta say you ranked this too high. This is one of the worst episodes in any Trek series. I can’t give it a lower rating than the clip show but this has to be a 1 of 10. Brahms reaction in the second half of the episode would be equivilent to Troi being all lovey dovey with the Ullian in Violations. What makes these two Brahms episodes even worse is the implication that these two get together in the end. Awful.

Avatar
Matt Doyle
12 years ago

Agreed. It was more or less fine up until the point where she confronts him with his behavior, but how they handle that is outrageous. LaForge and only LaForge is at fault, and not calling him out on it is reprehensible, taantamount to an endorsement of stalking.

However, at a guess, I would say (pessimistically) that this behavior doesn’t get any official reprimand because it simply can’t be uncommon. If public computer databases contain a level of personal information about celebrities sufficient for the holodeck to create plausible simulations of them… Barclay and Geordi aren’t going to be the only ones in this situation.

Many socially awkward, lonely people would regularly turn to the holodeck for fantasies of sex, romance… even just friendship. Star Trek: Voyager deals more with the ramifications of this (in what is arguably the best facet of Voyager — the way they explore the mental state of the crew through their use of the holodeck is extremely engaging), but what’s lacking, anywhere, is a sign that Starfleet recognizes and addresses the potential for abuse in any systematic way. there ought to be Academy courses on holo-ethics, with an emphasis on marking that line between fantasy and reality and keeping people from displaying this kind of entitled bullshit. Even just a throwaway line indicating some kind of sensitivity training (and signing Geordi up for a remedial course) would have helped a lot.

Avatar
John R. Ellis
12 years ago

I have to admit, they totally dropped the ball with this one. This is a case where the Star Trek Main Character Morality Shield ™ should have been lowered and Geordi should have been raked over the coals.

Even as a teen, the big rant by Geordi about how “I was trying to be NICE” (yeah, nice based on an extended romantic fantasy) left me feeling ill.

Avatar
12 years ago

Isn’t this the episode where the voices are completely unsynched with the actors’ lips? The part where Geordi is shouting at Leah is so painful to watch because the synch is absolutely glaring.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined