Pirates are always a good decision. It sounds like a trite thing to say, but it’s true; pirates, whether they’re heroes, villains, or somewhere in between, are perfect characters for adventure, mystery, fighting the powerful, serious ruminations on social and economic hierarchies, you name it. They rely on their own abilities and create their own fates. They aren’t always helpful, but they’re never boring. With that in mind, we’ve amassed a list of some of our favorite fantastical scalawags and the books they come from. Heave to it, and check them out!
Captain Hook (Peter Pan by J.M. Barrie)
It’s a cliché for sure, but it’s hard not to love Peter’s greatest foe, Captain James Hook. Peter Pan’s status as a beloved children’s classic means that there are so many iterations to choose from, so you’re bound to find a Hook that fit your particular needs. Whether you love the classic villain of Barrie’s book (and play), the foppish glee of the musical, the needy petulance of the captain in his own eponymous film, or the smolder of Once Upon a Time’s rogue, Captain Hook is always here for you, and there’s no right version because all are equally valid. Okay, we might give a bit of a leg up to Jason Isaacs from the 2003 film. He’s fabulous.
Buy the Book
Peter Pan
Teriana (Dark Shores by Danielle L. Jensen)
This YA adventure takes place in a world where there are a special class of people who navigate the seas called the Maarin. Heir to their Triumvirate is Teriana, the second mate of a ship called the Quincense, paired with a solider of the Celendor Empire named Marcus on a journey to conquer a place called the Dark Shores. It sounds daring and exciting, sure, but when you’re a pirate matched up with a guy holding onto a secret, and you’re being asked to use your ship and crew for an impossible quest that force you to break the rules of your people… well, it’s not great. Teriana is still up to the task though, and seeing as this is book one of a series, she’s got a long way to go and many more adventures to unpack.
Buy the Book
Dark Shores
Captain Shakespeare (Stardust by Neil Gaiman)
In the book, Tristran Thorne and the star Yvaine accidentally get themselves stuck in sky when they try to travel by candle, and wander among the clouds for a bit before stumbling upon a sky pirate and his crew. This interlude in the story is wonderful, but these particular pirates were given even more to chew on in the 2007 film version of Stardust, which named the head pirate Captain Shakespeare and saw him played by none other than Robert De Niro. Shakespeare is obviously a queer man in this version, and he has a wonderful time confiding in Tristan and Yvaine about the closet full of luxurious dresses and makeup that he keeps on board. Later he finds out that he crew knows all about his alter ego, and they still love him dearly. Supportive pirate crews FTW, y’all.
Buy the Book
Stardust
Li (The Pirate Empress by Deborah Cannon)
A pirate of circumstance, Cannon’s protagonist Li is actually a princess during China’s Ming Dynasty with a prophecy attached to her name—one that declares she will bear the Son of Heaven, a future emperor. Li has to leave her home after her son is kidnapped, and without help from her grandfather (who’s a warlock) or her lover, she finds herself forced into marriage with a pirate admiral. She has to learn quickly in order to ensure her survival in the hopes that she will find her son, and also defeat the Fox Faerie, a being with magic so corrupt and terrible, it threatens human civilization as we know it. This story showcases the darker side of pirate life, but if you’re intrigued by Chinese mythology and history, you’re sure to love Li’s journey.
Buy the Book
The Pirate Empress
Devyl Bane (Deadmen Walking by Sherrilyn Kenyon)
In the 1980s and ’90s, Sherrilyn Kenyon wrote pirate romances like A Pirate of Her Own under the name Kinley MacGregor. And as the descendant of historical pirate Jonathan Barnet—who apprehended Anne Bonny, among other famous swashbucklers—she has a personal investment in these stories. So when she returned to that world for the Deadman’s Cross series, readers rejoiced—especially when she threw fan favorite Thorn into the fray. The immortal Hellchaser strikes up an uneasy partnership with Devyl Bane, a warlord brought back to the human realm as a pirate on the Spanish Main, in order to push back demons threatening to break down the gates between worlds. Thorn, Bane, and their crew of Deadmen must sail on the Sea Witch—a ship, but also a woman with her own personal stakes in this conflict—to try and save humanity.
Buy the Book
Deadmen Walking
Rolfe (The Assassin’s Blade by Sarah J. Maas)
Like all good pirates, Rolfe receives his title (of Pirate Lord of Skull’s Bay) through a shaky bargain—in his case, the intervention of the Sea God, a magical map inked onto his palms, and the loss of all that he holds dear. But when he meets assassins Celaena Sardothien and Sam Cortland in the Throne of Glass novella The Assassin and the Pirate Lord, Rolfe is the one setting the negotiations. Led as much by his pragmatism as by a compass, the Lord of Ilium (as he is also known) will make questionably ethical choices when it comes to wiping out his enemies. But he is no monster, and will go to great lengths to save others from suffering bad fortunes like the one that first made him Pirate Lord.
Buy the Book
The Assassin's Blade
Kazan Atrabiades (Kushiel’s Chosen by Jacqueline Carey)
While Phèdre nó Delaunay gets swept up in a frustratingly long side-quest in the second Kushiel novel, she could do worse when it comes to adventuring companions. Illyrian pirate Kazan rescues the anguisette after she escapes the island fortress of La Dolorosa, but instead of taking her straight to her allies, he brings his beautiful and intriguing hostage along on his own quest for redemption. Cursed by his own mother with a blood-guilt due to accidentally murdering his brother in battle, Kazan is stalked by the fiery-eyed kríavbhog, forbidden from returning home until he has ritualistically cleansed his soul in the thetalos ceremony. While Kazan initially comes across as little more than a rogue, demanding Phèdre’s particular skills as a Servant of Naamah in exchange for his help, during their voyage he slowly opens up. By the time they part, he has proven himself a brave, surprisingly sensitive man who has come to respect her as more than a body, more than a bargaining chip, even eventually apologizing for their imbalanced arrangement.
Buy the Book
Kushiel's Chosen
Sim (The Lady’s Guide to Petticoats and Piracy by Mackenzi Lee)
Facing down the prospect of a stultifying marriage that will forever dash her dreams of becoming a doctor, Felicity Montague makes a last-ditch attempt to attain her dream: become the research assistant to an eccentric physician who happens to be marrying her estranged best friend. But the wedding is taking place in Germany, and Felicity has no way of getting there from London… until a mysterious young woman offers to finance her voyage, if Felicity will let her tag along pretending to be her maid. This odd request is Felicity’s first dealing with sword-wielding Algerian Muslim pirate Simmaa “Sim” Aldajah—but as they take to the high seas and Sim’s true intentions begin to surface, Felicity gets swept along in the kind of high-stakes adventure she never could have imagined. Once runaway bride Johanna Hoffman enters into the story, this trio makes for compelling leads with their own unique dynamics, from Felicity and Johanna’s adolescent strife to Sim’s attraction to Felicity tempered by their clashes over colonialism. While Johanna and Felicity each grapple with their identities with regard to attraction and societal norms of femininity, Sim must prove that she deserves her birthright, to inherit her father’s fleet of pirate ships.
Buy the Book
The Lady's Guide to Petticoats and Piracy
Lila Bard (A Darker Shade of Magic by V.E. Schwab)
When we meet Delilah Bard in A Darker Shade of Magic, she hasn’t actually made it as a pirate just yet. It’s more of a longterm goal, one that she’s working toward by picking pockets and living on a docked old boat that will likely never sail again. (It’s just as well, as said boat later goes up in flames.) Lila’s luck changes when she meets a young man named Kell who heralds from Red London, an alternate universe of sorts where magic is everywhere. Lila follows him through to that world and quickly gets herself a job as a thief on a ship called the Night Spire, deposing the thief who came before her. Lila’s ambition takes her everywhere fast, though, and it’s not long before the Night Spire is hers. She contributes far more to the story than her thieving prowess and desire to sail the seas, but Lila’s pirate aspirations are a part of her wanderlust and charms.
Buy the Book
A Darker Shade of Magic
Zamira Drakasha (Red Seas Under Red Skies by Scott Lynch)
Scott Lynch’s Gentleman Bastard series is full of glorious crooks and swindlers and liberators of wealth, but it isn’t until the second book that we get to meet a genuine swashbuckler who makes us swoon. Zamira Drakasha is the pirate queen of all our hearts, member of the Council of Pirate Captains and commander of a ship called the Poison Orchid. She is the sort of pirate one rarely sees in fiction: she’s a mother of two, two toddlers to be precise, named Paolo and Cossetta. She’s also in her forties, another rarity on the adventuring front for women. Imagine being a good enough pirate that you could keep your children on your pirate ship and just let them hang around while you plundered and otherwise owned the seas. Imagine being a boss like Zamira Drakasha.
Buy the Book
Red Seas Under Red Skies
The Piracy (The Nature of a Pirate by A.M. Dellamonica)
The pirates on this list are, for the most part, positive figures; their struggles inspire sympathy, even if we disagree with their general looting and plundering. It’s more difficult to make that case for the Piracy, the central villains of A.M. Dellamonica’s Stormwrack series. As antagonists, they are incredibly fitting for the waterlogged world of Stormwrack, made up of island nations literally struggling to stay afloat and a central governing body containing hundreds of ships always moving with the tide. For the first two books, the Piracy are clearly the bad guys, attacking the Fleet of Nations in its weakest spots in order to physically and figuratively break up its shaky peace. But that’s not how the pirates see it: Dellamonica wrote a compelling essay reframing piracy as a cultural construct, what began with five island nations going rogue but has grown into a way of life. “How do you dress, think, feel, and talk if you’re a pirate who can’t openly practice piracy?” she asks. “As a defeated nation with a bloody reputation, what do you teach your sons and daughters about the past?” While the Stormwrack series is mostly from the perspective of a young woman from Earth and her fellow crew on the Nightjar, the final installment of the trilogy ponders survival on the seas from all sides.
Buy the Book
The Nature of a Pirate
Who are your favorite buccaneers in fantasy?
Kazan! One of my faves!
Wesley, the current Dread Pirate Roberts in The Princess Bride.
Thanks for reading my musings.
AndrewHB
@2 AndrewHB
That one certainly leaps to mind, also I think of Belit from Robert E. Howard’s works.
Robin Hobb’s Pirates from the ship of magic series
Artemesia from Tanith Lee’s Piratica books.
Bêlit from Robert E. Howard’s “Queen of the Black Coast”. And I think Conan did some reaving on the high seas himself at various points.
Not strictly genre, but I have to mention Jacky Faber from L.A. Meyer’s Bloody Jack series.
Corin Hugh from The Godlanders War trilogy by Aaron Pogue.
(The Dreams of a Dying God, The Wrath of a Shipless Pirate, The Dawn of a Desperate War)
Captain Shakespeare was a huge departure from the book, but the thing is, I don’t remember anything about the pirate interlude in the book other than the first mate healed Tristran’s hand and Yvaine’s leg (more or less) and gave Yvaine a blue dress. The Captain Shakespeare interlude in the movie was far more memorable and funny (especially the “we always knew” line and poor Ferdy the Fence).
@2 He did not do much pirating, though…
We should also acknowledge the misfortunate pirates appearing in various Asterix stories, usually losing their ship soon after meeting our heroes.
Which reminds me of the Galavant and the lords of the sea (just, not of the actual sea).
@7, In the books, there is this entire cabal of unnamed characters who are ensuring the events happen as they do, and the pirate Captain was one of them.
That bit actually aggravated me a bit, having seen the movie first I knew there were differences, but I hate unanswered questions.
Well, since you included Lila and Zamira, I think the only other name I could add would be Jack Shandy from Tim Powers’ On Stranger Tides.
Oh and if we’re going outside of print, then most definitely Guybrush Threepwood, Elaine Marley, and ghost pirate LeChuck
@9, well to be fair, it’s also mostly unanswered in the book as well.
I have to go with the Crimson Permanent Assurance here
Peter the Priate King from Galavant…
Deadman walking <3
Hmm. Apparently I have to do a lot of catching up, as I only have read two or three of these books.
Re Captain Shakespeare: I’ll be the dissenting voice here. I barely remember the book’s captain –and, IIRC, they weren’t even pirates, just lighting hunters– and, while I liked the movie concept of the queer pirate captain who is a secret transvestite, Robert De Niro was about as gruffly bland as he has been in the past 20 years. Alas, why didn’t they cast Al Pacino? He would have had a ball with that role.
Oh. As for my favorite buccaneer, I’d have to say all those played by Errol Flynn. I know those weren’t technically fantasy movies, but –weren’t they?
@11,That’s what I was saying, I hated how it went unanswered in the books, and the fact that it’s cut from the movie makes me like it more.
@@@@@ 7, 9, and 11: They were the Secret Society of Something or Other (can’t remember the real name), for which Tristram ended up working in the end when he took the crown.
To be frank, I kinda liked the way the book left a lot of things unanswered. Like, what was the god Dionysus doing posing as a pub owner in that town? Also, there were other supernatural characters coming from our world through the Wall. Not to mention the whole backstory of the Lilim, the daughters of Lilith, who once ruled the world.
@17, I guess my problem is that I saw the movie then read the book, and I liked what the movie did better.
But I do hate unanswered questions in fiction.
Jim Butcher’s Aeronaut’s Windlass introduces a great ‘privateer’ captain and crew. Captain Grimm is who I want to be when I grow up.
@18: I like the main things in the story resolved. But a lot of other things are better left to the imagination. They’re richer that way.
Senlin and Edith sailing the Stone Cloud around the Tower of Babel? And that, as I recall, was only the start of Edith’s piratical career.
Missie Lee, from the Arthur Ransome book of the same name.
+1 For Zamira, her actual competency as a Captain is appealing.
Amos Trask deserves a mention – yes he’s cliché (you can actually almost imagine him saying “Billions of blue blistering barnacles” while Tin Tin watches on) but it was written long enough ago that he kinda built the cliché rather than plagiarised it.
@15 Ashgrove
Errol Flynn is an admirably solid choice.
Does Morgan Adams from Cutthroat Island count as fantasy?
I agree with Andrew, Dread Pirate Roberts![.](//s04.flagcounter.com/mini/Jkzv/bg_FFFFFF/txt_CCCCCC/border_DBDBDB/flags_0/" alt="Free counters!" border="0"></a>)
There’s actually a TVTropes entry for “The Pirates That Never Do Anything” and it’s worth considering how many on this list fit the category; or even aren’t pirates at all, like Captain Shakespeare, who’s really more of an illegal fisherman. The ones who we actually see engaged in piracy – armed robbery with violence on the high seas – tend to be a bit less popular. (The Dread Pirate Roberts does all his murder offstage, and there is a lot of it.)
The Kielmark, from Janny Wurts’ Cycle of Fire trilogy.
@23 line
Checks out.
For heroic pirates who don’t do much in the way of actual piracy, I’ve become very fond Captain Monkey D. Luffy and the rest of his Straw Hat pirate crew. The <i>One Piece</i> long-running manga has lots of other supporting pirate characters, many loosely based on real-life pirates.
The sky pirates in the Edge Chronicles. Especially Cloud Wolf/Quint.
‘Stardust’ the movie is way better than ‘Stardust’ the novel.
There. I said it.
Vikram Szpirglas from Kenneth Oppel’s Airborn gets my vote for best (airship) pirate and for best character ever to be eaten by flying cats.
@crane 29 Crane.
I just realised how that should be the lyrics of a Dropkick Murphys’ song.
@@@@@ 32: I LOVE both, but I like the book better. It is always poetic, which the movie never really is.
I do find that, when the movie gets something right, it does it better than the book. Case in point:
*SPOILERS* *SPOILERS* *SPOILERS* *SPOILERS* *SPOILERS* *SPOILERS*
In the book, after building a lot of anticipation, the witch subplot basically, and disappointingly, sputters out. There the movie doesn’t disappoint: the witches go off with a literal bang. (And a very satisfying one at that.)
And, while I love the melancholy ending of the novel, the movie’s happy ending may be saccharine, but it makes much more sense than the book’s, since Yvaine did give Tristan her heart, so he should at least have lived longer than a regular mortal life (not to mention that he was half fairy).
@15, @24 – Errol Flynn ‘s Captain Blood was based on the novels of Rafael Sabatini, which I remember fondly from my school days.
@@@@@ 36: So do I! But I saw the movie way before I read the novel.
Errol Flynn was my first crush. I watched his Robin Hood in a movie theater being very, very young (like 4 or 5, tops), and I will always remember his entrance carrying a deer on his shoulders.
@@@@@ 24: Bet.
Uh, you guys forgot the actual right answer, Sea Hawk.
@@@@@22. PamAdams:
If you can mention MisseeLee, then *I* will vote for Captain Flint.
No love for the undead with ravenous sexual appetites? For shame. Arguably one of Erikson’s greatest characters, Shurq Elalle, pirate extraordinaire, though admittedly we don’t get to see much of her Piratey exploits until book 7, it’s worth the wait.
https://malazan.fandom.com/wiki/Shurq_Elalle
Malcom “Mal” Reynolds (Serenity/Firefly) enuf said !!! (read most of these – also love these pirates as well)
Always, always here for pirates, and VERY intrigued to learn about that Tanith Lee series. Her Wolf Tower series is one of my favorites of all time, but I’ve had trouble getting into her adult stuff. Though maybe I’m due to give it another try.
When I was a young lass in college and Stardust came out, I was annoyed at how different it was from the book, but as the years have gone on, I’ve come to appreciate it more and more as its own wonderful fantasy adventure. So much of what I love about the book (its bittersweetness, the subtleties of how the two worlds are intertwined) wouldn’t have worked nearly as well onscreen, and the movie is such a joy, with a bunch of actors I really like just having a pretty wonderful time. I never really connected with Princess Bride, but Stardust is definitely my Princess Bride equivalent.
Tristan’s last scene with Victoria remains one of my favorite moments ever in a fantasy movie. The coat, the sword, the swelling music . . . “You want to grow up. And get over yourself.” Ah! I love it. :)
I concur with the Dread Pirate Roberts.
Also, John Shandy from Tim Powers’ On Stranger Tides.
I have to vote for elf pirate Phaelan Benares from Lisa Shearin’s Raine Benares series.
Where is Anne Bonney from R.S. Belcher’s Queen of Swords?
If you’re including Captain Hook, you should include another classic pirate, Long John Silver.
I definitely agree with the Dread Pirate Roberts and Captain Shakespeare, though.
No Captain Frey of the Ketty Jay? Boo this list.
Loved Stardust! My favorite airship pirate is Mister Bale in The Wake of the Dragon by Jaq D. Hawkins. Captain Bonney was a great character but Mister Bale had that magical Jack Sparrow quality.
Emer Morrisey, Dust of 100 Dogs. A strangle little YA novel, but I liked the character.
Boltar from Prince Valiant should be included in the list. A Viking-pirate with a big axe!
@42: Mal for ever!!!!!!! (“And that is not incense.”)
A pirate I’d KILL to read about is Maia’s queer pirate aunt from The Goblin Emperor.
The “Bloody Jack” series about Mary “Jacky” Faber by L.A. Meyer
how do you fail to list the Dread Pirate Roberts from The Princess Bride?
How?
Inda!
I don’t know how willing everybody is about stretching genre definitions, but Ted Cruz’ talk about ‘space pirates’ has got me watching the original 1970s ‘Captain Harlock: Space Pirate’ anime.
Space Pirates makes me think of the Robert Ulrich vehicle of the early 80’s, Ice Pirates.
How about Chase the Morning and sequels by Michael Scott Rohan?
I second Inda. Also Zenida Okanas from Draconis Memoria by Anthony Ryan
Arithon from Janny Wurts The Ships of Merior
@5 hoopmanjh and @43 onfairystories – YES! Yay to Tanith Lee’s Piratica stories! And 43 I agree – I have struggled with her adult stuff but loved Wolf Tower series so much – so unique and sticky in my brain unlike so many other derivative things that go in one eyeball and out the other.
genre is sf, Alastair Reynolds Revenger and Shadow Captain
It should be illegal to make a list of fantasy pirates that doesn’t include Jack Shandy from On Stranger Tides.
My favorite pirate is real–William Dampier, the subject of A PIRATE OF EXQUISITE MIND. He wasn’t nearly as good at pirating as some of his contemporaries, but he was excellent at sending home papers of this and that to the Royal Society. His life was widely copied for various works of literature, and I plan on steal–er, researching, yes, must remember the word researching whilst filching kibbles and bits.
One of my all time favorites: Bloody Jack: Being an Account of the Curious Adventures of Mary ‘Jacky’ Faber, Ship’s Boy (Bloody Jack Adventures Book 1). The books are hilarious. If you are into audiobooks, that is a great way to experience this 12 book series.
I would like to nominate Hannah Mabbot from “Cinnamon and Gunpowder” by Eli Brown, a truly piratical captain with a taste for fine food. Historical fiction/adventure.
Nancy A. Hansen’s meticulously researched Jezebel Johnston series from Airship 27 is well worth a look.