And here we are. It feels almost sad, getting to the last of the Firefly Re-watch. Yeah, I’ll still have some comics to talk about after this (in a bit, they are in the mail), but I’m going to format those a bit differently than I did with Those Left Behind, if for no other reason than to save the taxonomy of “re-watch.” I am breaking this up into two parts, though, splitting right about halfway through the movie. Even more, this is going to be a little different, so hang on as I stream-of-consciousness this baby!
Prologue
Right, so, the movie starts by opening before the series ever did, with a history lesson about Earth-that-was in a crazy school setting. River questions her teacher, only to be stabbed in the forehead. Of course, she is really strapped to a chair, being tested on and observed while she sleeps and a nervous doctor exposits about her to some military review dude. Not just any review dude, though. It’s Simon! Simon executes a daring rescue, and they escape just before the shaft they are in fills with lasers.
The scene freezes, and an ominous yet soft spoken and polite man walks through the hologram projection. The same scientist that was talking to Simon walks in, demanding to know who this ominous man is. The man accesses a computer that pulls up his file, which has no name or rank, but simply identifies him as an Operative of the Parliament. The doctor is suddenly much more cordial, tries to cover his bum about what happened, but ends up dead on the Operative’s sword. The Operative then has a lower ranking doctor pull the files on River and her behavior conditioning.
My Thoughts
Ok, I have three sets of thoughts on this: when I first saw the movie, when I saw it after having seen the series, and now, seeing it after reading Those Left Behind.
First time I saw this, seeing it only as a stand alone movie with no clue what Firefly was, I was pretty impressed with the scene. Of course, I was confused a bit chronologically. See, the way this is shot, it makes it seem like the Operative is viewing the security logs a few days at most after the break-out. Later in the movie, Mal states that River and Simon have been on his ship for eight months, making me wonder what a horrible tracker the Operative really was and leaving what I thought was a glaring plot hole. All in all, though, I did enjoy it, as it set up tension and a main villain at the onset, which are two things I think the opening of any story really should do.
So, some years after I had seen it, I find out about the show, watch it, then watch the movie again. Wow, was my impression a bit different. I wondered at Simon’s seeming idiocy during the series when he clearly states that she is a psychic as he is breaking her out, in addition to knowing that she has combat aptitude. The Operative really confused me as I had no clue where the Blue-Hands went (even though I think they are briefly sorta cameo’d in the breakout as security, although they didn’t have blue hands). I also was still chronologically confused, as I still had the impression the Operative was a few days after the breakout.
And now, it all makes sense. Blue-hands were burned out, this is happening a few days after Those Left Behind, and thus probably concurrently with the next scene. I also am a little more forgiving of Simon’s badassery after having looked through the series with a more critical eye. I think he could have pulled that off, especially with the Operative’s lovely quote.
OPERATIVE: Madness? Have you looked at this scan carefully, Doctor? At his face? It’s love, in point of fact. Something a good deal more dangerous.
That’s almost as good as a certain other madness quote. Also, from the discussion in the Re-watch, I am a little more forgiving of Simon’s “ignorance” in the series. He is like a few friends of mine. No matter how much said friends need your help, they still only tell you the bare minimum—unless they really trust you—because they really just play it close to their chest. Simon, already a stellar example of someone who can make some poor decisions, makes the call to hide her psychic powers and possible war training.
Oh, and just as a bit of a goof, I was reading in IMDB about how this is supposed to take place 6 months after “Objects in Space.” Yet “Our Mrs. Reynolds” happens about 6 months before “Trash” by Mal’s quote in “Trash.” So that requires at least a year of time that Simon and Mal have been together, so the 8 month thing later is screwed up. Oh well, I’ll just squint and nod.
The Heist, River goes Crazy (twice), and a Character out of the Blue
Aboard the Serenity, we get a quintessential feel for everyone. Mal is the captain, watching and barking orders, Wash is the deadpan snarker under stress, Jayne likes guns, Zoe is a voice of reason and married to Wash, Kaylee is the mechanic, Simon is protective of River, and River is a little loose in the noggin’. The crew is going to knock over a payroll for a local security force, and River has to come along so she can sniff out trouble with her brain-juju before it happens. Mal makes it clear that Simon is an unwelcome presence on the ship and there because he has a useful talent (but is not one of the crew), and that he had better not back-talk Mal.
On the planet, the heist goes pretty smoothly. Mal finds the vault, and River tips Zoe off on a would-be hero, full with a good quote.
Zoe: Do you know what the definition of a hero is? Someone who gets other people killed. You can look it up later.
Then, as Mal is taking care of the vault, River goes crazy and feels Reavers approaching, who quickly set about to raiding the town. Mal orders the townfolk in the tavern into the vault and then he and the crew make off on the mule. Alas, the would-be hero tries to tag along, and Mal kicks him off to be caught by Reavers. Mal at least has the grace to put the man out of his misery. A wonderful hovercraft chase then ensues, where Wash and Zoe do some crazy piloting/driving and “barn swallow” the mule mid-flight, with a bit of the Reaver ship too.
Simon goes berserk at how much danger River was put in and punches Mal, then announces he is getting off at the next stop. Mal, who is rather upset for obvious reasons, says fine and they part ways. In the midst of this, a Reaver pops out of the wreckage and gets riddled with bullet holes. Jayne then gives some exposition on what Reavers are, and there is mention of Book and Inara.
They get to Beaumonde, where Kaylee is rather choked up as she gives Simon advice on finding a new ship to move around on, and then gets rather upset at Mal in the Maidenhead, a weapons-free bar where Mal is dropping off his employers’ cut of the job. The employers, Fanty and Mingo, make some snide comments and accuse Mal of being unreliable and demand more for their cut. Before it can get too far, River walks in and sees a crazy commercial that triggers her to say “Miranda” and turns her into a killing machine that takes down pretty much the entire bar single-handedly, which includes beating the snot out of Jayne. Mal and her draw guns on each other just as Simon rushes in and screams out a “safeword” that makes River pass out. Mal then spirits her away.
The Operative, being sneaky like he is, watches the whole thing on the security feed. He then identifies Mal and goes to whatever planet Inara is living on now and wordlessly meets her.
Back on Serenity, River is locked in a pantry and the crew grill Simon about what happened. He admits to what he has known but held back, and then Jayne wonders why they are even back on board and calls Mal out on it. Before Mal can respond, Simon shifts topics to ask to see her. Wash then suggests they talk to “Mr. Universe.” In the cupboard, River rambles in her usual way that seems to say one thing but means another (mainly her being dangerous, but she means to the Alliance, not the crew). On the bridge, Mr. Universe reveals that River said “Miranda” to the crew, in addition to saying someone else has seen the feed and that there was some heavy military stuff encoded in the video that triggered River. Mal decides they need to go lay low, so they head to Haven, where Shepherd Book now lives.
Thoughts
Okay, same as last time. When I first watched all this, I was super confused. Book and Inara? Who was she? Who was he? What is all this implied emotional baggage that I’m not getting? River’s crazy beat-everyone-up was awesome (and is fodder for the best movie idea ever). Oddly enough, on the confusion stuff, this set of scenes also introduced a character that has only become more and more confusing to me: Mr. Universe. I get who and what he is, what his plot function is, but there is such an implication of “we know this guy” when really, no, we don’t. Not ever. And considering he and his planet become kind of plot critical, I just keep getting confused.
After I watched the series, I at least understood Inara, but Book confused the snot out of me still. Why did he leave? Was that really necessary? Well, in foresight, yes, but I’ll get there and to one of Whedon’s trademarks. There is also the confusion of Mal’s attitude towards Simon. Now, they were never close in the series, I know, but at the same time, Mal actually made it really clear that Simon and River were, for better or worse, part of the crew now, especially in “Safe.” Where did this who animosity and “us/them” thing come from?
It wasn’t even set up in the comic, where Simon and River play next to no part at all to the main action and have zilch interaction with Mal. At least the comic answered where Book went and gave us the solid “Inara has left” feeling, although that was easily extrapolated from the show. Regardless, I was not too happy with the clumsy way Book and Inara are introduced to the movie.
Whedon was obviously hoping to catch a lot of new audience with this, what with the Reaver exposition and such, but I almost think he would have been better off leaving out the complications of Book and Inara being off-ship yet still part of the crew’s complex past.
And, just a random thought: why the crazy sam-hell was River wandering alone into a seedy bar? I know Simon has a penchant for not being able to keep an eye on her, but he was pretty durn slow on catching up.
Moving on, I also noticed that this movie fell prey to “series-to-movie upgrades.” I don’t know if there is an actual trope for this, but it seems that with rare exception, when a series becomes a movie, all the technology becomes amazingly more detailed and advanced and the entire cast gets a wardrobe upgrade. Heck, it happens often between movies (The Star Trek: Next Generation movies, anyone?). I actually really love how Star Trek II–VI managed to keep a pretty steady look (and upgrades had in-show reasons, like a new ship). But I digress.
Serenity herself is upgraded in many ways, from the mule being a hovercraft now to the main cargo door doing this nifty slidy thing when it opens instead of just having standard hydraulics. Now, I understand they have 2 years of CGI industry advancement and a larger budget and all that, plus the original set was destroyed. And I can forgive the mule because, as Whedon says, if you are going to make a sci-fi movie, you need to have an awesome hovercraft chase. But the upgrades to the ship? Ugh. It kind of broke the spell for me as a returning watcher. Yes, make the graphics sharper and cleaner and stuff and give me awesome pans around the ship and all that. But changing the ship? Please, no.
And what was with everyone having odd strips of fabric, leather, or rubber on their costumes? (What was up with Wash’s harness thing? Really.) Mal has little horizontal strips on his shirt, Zoe’s leather vest is more streamlined, Simon is wearing a more Chinese-inspired shirt most of the time, etc. Heck, I think Kaylee is the only one who didn’t really get a wardrobe upgrade, but that’s because out of everyone else she wore the most diverse costumes on the show. But for everyone else, to steal a meme, I am disappoint. One thing I loved about Firefly was how the costumes weren’t “sci-fi.” There were small stylistic things here and there, but a button-down shirt was still a button-down shirt, and Hawaiian shirts still existed. Just a small rant, though.
Haven and a Trap
So the crew makes it to Haven, where we get a bit of a montage that they know the people there, not just Book, and that this is a place they can take their ease. Mal and Book have a conversation about what is going on, and Book tells Mal that he is dealing with an Operative now, which is unlike anything he has ever had to deal with before. His only advice, aside from that the Operative is never going to come straight at Mal, is for Mal to find faith, although not in God, just in something.
Back aboard the ship, Mal gets a wave from Inara, who awkwardly asks Mal to come and help them with an issue with the locals. The entire crew eavesdrops on the conversation, and when Mal comes up to the bridge, he declares that it is a trap and they are going to see Inara anyway. When Kaylee asks how he knows it is a trap, he calls them out on eavesdropping, but then asks them if they saw them fight. No? Then it must be a trap.
On Inara’s planet, Mal sneaks up to her wearing a voluminous robe and she gets ten sorts of mad at him for actually coming. He professes that he knew it was a trap and came to help her, but she insists he needs to leave anyway as “this man” is beyond Mal. The Operative then walks in, but he does not attack. Instead he tries to reason with Mal, calls Mal out on playing little games, threatens Mal and his ship (which Mal quickly disarms by being crafty), then beats the crap out of Mal after Mal unsuccessfully tries to pull a Han Solo vs Greedo. Inara ends up saving the day with a flash-bomb she set when the Operative walked in, and the two escape back to the ship. The ship then deploys several decoys and loses the Operative.
Thoughts
Oh, that’s Book! On my first watch, I kind of forgave Whedon for the more or less simple life Book is given in the narrative. He is a friend and a confidant, a person who lets brigands lay low when needed. The little “you need to tell me about your past sometime/no I don’t” thing was lost on me for it’s deeper purpose, but I got it. The Inara scene, of course, just kind of left me feeling like I was being forced to accept a relationship as deep, which I guess in some ways works because it was deep, I just didn’t know. But with all the other stuff that is kind of being thrown at us in media res style, it really comes off more forced. The same trick being used too many times, I guess. The fight in the Companion compound was pretty awesome, though.
Post series-watching, I was confused in different way. I still had no clue why Book was at Haven, and Inara’s little would-be request about locals giving a house of registered companions trouble seemed even too thin to use for a “yes this is a trap but I’m not really saying it.” Yes, Nandi and crew needed to ask for help, but they were honest-to-goodness whores and had no social standing. Even if it was a more “rim” world this training house is on, for Companions to need to call a random brigand for help? I doubt the Operative would have bought that, and it really makes the “Did we fight? No? Trap!” line cute but superfluous. Still, the fight scene rocked (and bulletproof body armor is even established from the “Serenity” pilot episode.)
Post comic, well, at least I know why Book left and is on Haven. I am glad that he still welcomes his old friends, though. I guess he still wants to be in contact with them to either continue to try and give himself some temptation (one of my theories on why he was on Serenity in the first place) or to continue to try and convert them (which I highly doubt, all things taken in). With the implication that Inara is on Sihnon from the comic, though, I am somewhat confused. I guess it just seems like the ‘verse got oddly small. Sihnon is a central planet and Mal makes a hub-bub about how long it takes to get there (and we know even some rim-travel takes weeks at a time.) Miranda is in Reaver territory, which is on the rim. Beaumonde might not be core, but it is decently put up, akin to Persephone, (heck, Badger even knows Fanty and Mingo), so yeah, a day or less travel here or there seems kind of, um, off? Granted, it keeps the action and tension from seeming too drag (same reason the first hour of Fellowship of the Ring happens in weeks instead of years.)
Intermission
I think that is long enough for now. Tune in next week for the second half, in which River Tam truly does beat everyone up!
Richard Fife is a writer, blogger, and advocate of swords in space, because they are just too cool to ever be left behind. You can read more of his ramblings and some of his short fiction at http://RichardFife.com.
In the hologram scene, when the Operative quizzes the doctor about what would drive Simon to go to such extremes to rescue his sister, he answers himself: “It’s love, in point of fact.” Watch carefully, and you can see a hint of a snicker as he says it. My guess is that the script has him saying, “It’s love, actually,” which would be Whedon’s poke at Chiwetel Ejiofor, who was in the movie “Love, Actually.”
If you read the novelization of Serenity, you’ll find out that Wash and Mr. Universe knew each other in flight school, if I’m not mistaken. The backstory filled in that gap which, I agree, would have cleared up the ‘Who the hell is this guy’-ness of Mr. Universe’s appearance.
“Mal and her draw guns on each other”
Shouldn’t that be “Mal and she”? (I’m usually not one to pick too many nits, but it seemed a little jarring)
Anyhow, love the review/re-watch. I like that you relate how you thought with differing levels of background info.
The start of the movie was huge retcon of the series, but that’s ok, you need to squeeze a lot of information into a short space of time. That Simon rescued River rather than paying someone else to do it… ah well, it’s what the plot needed.
That Mal had River join a heist, over the objections of Simon… ok, a bit more squeezing of the series plot to fit a movie.
Inara… Book… sadly wasted, but no fault of the movie, how do you fit in the kind of back story that either of them deserved? I loved the hints that Book was ex-Government and was either on a quest for redemption (possibly for Miranda) or to keep an eye on River. Inara, I never got a good grasp on, knowing Wheedon, she wasn’t just there for romantic interest for Mal, but there was no way to go into her plot at all. So both Book and Inara’s back story were jettisoned for the movie… ok, fine, it’s movie and a movie has time constraints.
The first half of the movie were good as far as I saw, all the important movie bits were there, protagonists in Mal and River, the antagonist in the Operative. Though I must admit that the Operative was badly presented as an obvious ‘bad guy’ from the start. His appeals to Roman civic ethics notwithstanding, he’s cast as the person the ‘team River’ side must fight against.
That said, the tension between Simon and Mal in the opening scenes and the fall-out, leading to Mal throwing them off the ship gave a bit of body to it. Who exactly was the ‘hero’ at that point? Well Simon, but Mal soon takes over when he reverts to form later in the movie, but to the initiate, the Operative ad Mal are cast as separate but equally morally dubious characters until Mal takes the moral high ground and keeps it for the rest of the movie. Which led to a goodly amount of drama when it was needed, in the stretch before the popcorn/soda rush bathroom break movie walkout danger.
Too much was jettisoned from the TV plot to make it a full Firefly movie so far, but enough was kept to make it enjoyable to halfway.
Objections, your honor!
– Serenity (the movie) takes place about two months after the series, not six. There is no mention how much time has passed other than the eight month period Mal mentions. Which leaves the so inclined Firelfy aficionado to deduce that two months have passed since “Objects in Space”.
– Serenity (the ship) has always had the glidy-slidy cargo doors. The hydraulics were for the cargo ramp which still exists in the movie.
– The original mule was destroyed when being used as a weapon against Niska’s men in “War Stories”. Assuming the crew made mucho dinero with the Lassiter after “Trash” why not go for the floaty kind of mule?
– Inara is not on Sihnon. I don’t know where the comic is supposed to be hinting at that. If anything the movie strongly hints that she is NOT on Sihnon. You obviously don’t have “trouble with the locals” on an Alliance core world. So the Operative wouldn’t have made her say that unless it made at least some sense. Also, with all the hinted at not-aging Inara does and her need to hide that fact she definitely doesn’t want to settle down on her home-world.
And if she is in a training house close to the Rim, their “companion standing” is worth squat. Alliance simply isn’t present, so who you gonna call (Ghostbusters!) when you actually have trouble with the locals? Local law enforcement? Didn’t work for Nandi, wouldn’t work for Inara.
BTW, in “Objects in Space” Inara wanted to be dropped off on the not too distant New Melbourne which is a layover point for both core and border systems. And the comic ends in the remains of the Battle of Sturges which, given the fact that it was one of the largest battles between Alliance and Browncoats, isn’t very likely to be located in the core but more between Core and Border like Hera (the Battle of Serenity Valley). All that put together it is much more likely that Inara was dropped of on New Melbourne or another world along the Border instead of Serenity actually taking the long trip all the way back to Sihnon.
– Why shouldn’t Badger know (about) Fanty and Mingo? They are notorious criminals like him. They could have had dealings with each other in the past on any given world before they settled down on their respective worlds. Or they’ve just built up a reputation. Either way, that’s no implication that Persephone and Beaumonde are close to each other.
– Additionally, the Verse is very complex. It’s basically four solar systems (Blue Sun and Kalidasa in the Rim, Georgia and Red Sun in the Border) revolving around the central White Sun solar system, the Core. Depending on how those elements are aligned over the course of a year distances can vary significantly. Just think about Mars’ distance to Earth which varies between 55 Mio. km and 400 Mio. km. So what is a very long trip at a certain point can become a considerably shorter trip eight months later.
And just because we’re not shown long days of travel doesn’t mean there are none. ;)
“I still had no clue why Book was at Haven…”
He found a mission that was bigger than Serenity. Made sense to me.
“…and Inara’s little would-be request about locals giving a house of registered companions trouble seemed even too thin to use for a “yes this is a trap but I’m not really saying it.””
She left him. She’s requesting help for a relatively minor problem (one that Companions should have no problem with, BTW.) He reads between the lines. Again, made sense to me.
“I still had no clue why Book was at Haven…”
He found a mission that was bigger than Serenity. Made sense to me.
“…and Inara’s little would-be request about locals giving a house of registered companions trouble seemed even too thin to use for a “yes this is a trap but I’m not really saying it.””
She left him. She’s requesting help for a relatively minor problem (one that Companions should have no problem with, BTW.) He reads between the lines. Again, made sense to me.
Randalator @5-
Is there a map of the ‘Verse somewhere?
There are a number of maps of the ‘Verse online, although not all of them agree. The most detailed one doesn’t seem to be online in any kind of “useful” version, unfortunately (you can’t read any of the planet names); it seems to be a pointer to something you can buy. But it’ll give a basic idea as to the shape of things in the ‘Verse. Just Google “Map of the Verse” and you’ll find a bunch of ’em.
I came to the series late, watched it from the start and straight thru to the movie, and while I found the beginning of the film a little jarring (with everyone being at each others’ throats, and with Mal being so careless of River’s safety, just using her like that seemed dickish and unlike his previous fatherly concern towards her by OIS) the supposed Simon “retcon” made perfect sense to me, b/c from watching the series it was obvious (to me) that Simon knew of River’s psychic abilities at least as early as Safe, and gave a pretty clear indication he knew in Trash. I figured just what you did, that he was keeping it to himself out of caution (recall the people he trusted most in the verse – his parents – had already betrayed him, and those folks in safe tried to kill her out of fear, so you can’t really blame the guy for being wary). It also explained why he already knew how to break into high-security facilities. I also couldn’t figure out where the heck the Shepherd was – so the comics sure cleared all that up, but didn’t find them until after. My biggest complaint with the film was we didn’t get much Inara, her character seemed really incidental in the film. I know it was due to time and story issues but still sad.
sps49 @8
Like Jaquandor said, the official Map of the Verse cannot be found online in any useful resolution. But you can take a peek here to get an idea of how the Verse looks.
You can even make out enough to know that Beaumonde is the capital of the Kalidasa system (in the Rim) while Persephone is known to be part of the White Sun system (in the Core).
Additionally I just stumbled over the shooting script with a deleted scene (p. 40) mentioning that Inara is in a very remote (probably even the most remote) training house. And with Serenity just having left Beaumonde and being “just a few hours out” from Inara’s location it means that the training house is in Kalidasa, too.
That puts paid to R.fife’s criticism about short distances between Core and Rim. Depending on the alignment of the systems Kalidasa is the closest to Miranda’s Blue Sun system by a long shot, both being Rim systems.
I started with Serenity too. I didn’t really have a problem with Book and Inara appearing out of nowhere I accepted that Mal and co. knew them if I didn’t. I was genuinely surprised that Mr. Universe didn’t appear in Firefly.
God I love the Maidenhead fight!