At the time of writing, I’ve read approximately 230 new-to-me books in the past calendar year. Twenty-seven, according to my records, were nonfiction, and maybe another half-dozen were ARCs for books that won’t be out until next year. Of what’s left, a little over eighty were novels written or co-written by women published prior to 2014, and something over fifty were novels written or co-written by people who identify themselves as women and published in 2014.
If you’re interested in numbers, in 2014 I also read twenty-one books solely written by people who identify themselves as men which were published during said year, leaving about forty novels by blokes written prior to 2014. In percentages, 28.8% of 2014 novels which I read were by blokes, and 32% of all new-to-me novels. So 71.2% of new novels were by women, and 68% of novels overall. Next year I need to keep records on more grounds than merely gender, though, I think.
What I want to do in this post is talk a little about the kinds of new books I read in 2014, and what I think were the best of them. This is going to skew pretty heavily towards books by women, naturally, since with the exceptions of Max Gladstone’s Full Fathom Five, Django Wexler’s The Shadow Throne, David Drake’s The Sea Without A Shore, and the David Weber/Timothy Zahn collaboration A Call To Duty, nothing I read by a bloke this year thoroughly entertained me. (Don’t miss Full Fathom Five and The Shadow Throne. They’re pretty excellent. And the other two are thoroughly entertaining space opera.) Though I did like Charles Stross’s The Rhesus Chart, too: it’s just slighter than his usual run of Laundry novels.
My reading in general was fairly heavily biased towards fantasy, with some notable exceptions (Ann Leckie’s excellent Ancillary Sword, Karen Healey’s brilliant While We Run, Sophia McDougall’s Mars Evacuees, Stephanie Saulter’s satisfying Binary, and Ankaret Wells’ entertaining but flawed Heavy Ice among them), and towards a combination of epic and urban fantasy at that. I’m not much of a hard SF reader at the best of times, and this year definitely wasn’t the best of times.
For my money, the two best epic fantasies of the year were Katherine Addison’s The Goblin Emperor—I’d really love to see it make a few award lists in the coming months, because it is such a marvellous, delightful book—and Elizabeth Bear’s Steles of the Sky, the concluding volume in her SERIOUSLY EPIC Eternal Sky trilogy. That’s a book that really sticks its dismount, a book that makes you look at the preceding volumes in a freshly appreciative light. I don’t know that I’ve read another trilogy that does what Bear’s doing here quite so well—and I know for damn sure I haven’t read a concluding volume that pulls off its grand finale as well.
Roz Kaveney’s Resurrections is also epic fantasy of a sort. Epic, and urban, and contemporary, and endearingly blasphemous, and odd: the third book in a four-book sequence, I’ve been trying to think about how to discuss it ever since I read it, months ago. I really enjoyed reading it, but it’s one of those books where explaining why you enjoyed it (despite, or because of, its flaws) is something of a challenge, because it’s not much at all like anything else I’ve ever read.
Also not much like anything else out there is Elizabeth Bear’s One-Eyed Jack, a novel that relies for a lot of its effect on audience familiarity with spy shows of the 1960s—but if you’re even slightly familiar with those, works magnificently well.
Nnedi Okorafor’s Lagoon, too, feels interestingly unique. A first-contact story set in Lagos, it combines science fiction and a touch of what strikes me as magic realism to produce a very lively text, one that demands its readers pay attention.
Heather Rose Jones’ Daughter of Mystery doesn’t demand as much attention from its readers, but it’s a debut novel I’m thoroughly pleased to have read—and one which has joined the list of things I reread for comfort while I’m miserably ill. It’s a Ruritanian romance with fantastical elements set in the small Alpine country of Alpennia during the early part of the 19th century. In addition to being a Ruritanian romance, it’s also a lesbian one, with engaging characters and interesting incidents. It has its flaws, but it’s an awful lot of fun.
I’m not sure there’s anything (newly published, at least) under the urban fantasy rubric that got me particularly excited during 2014. I think I probably had the most fun reading Lia Silver’s Laura’s Wolf, a novel of werewolves, romance, and post-traumatic stress disorder: it’s certainly one of the handful that left more than a fleeting impression.
And in YA (a genre in which I confess I’m not very widely read), Sarah Rees Brennan’s Unmade, the conclusion to her Lynburn Legacy trilogy, packs a remarkable punch. A++, would cry again.
Those are the novels from 2014 that’ve stuck with me to the end of the year. What’s stuck with you?
Liz Bourke is a cranky person who reads books. Her blog. Her Twitter.
This year, I paid more attention to the gender of the writers I gravitated towards, and my faves wound up being about half and half. Genre-wise, I was 80% SFF/H, as per usual.
Women writers dominated the top half of the list, with The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison, The Mirror Empire by Kameron Hurley, Maplecroft by Cherie Priest, The Iron Khan by Liz Williams (any year I discover a Detective Inspector Wei Chen novel I haven’t read yet is a good year), and Through the Woods by Emily Carroll. I also binge-read my way through the Eli Monpress novels by Rachel Aaron (which were pretty awesome).
The rest of the list was The Girl with All the Gifts by MR Carey, The Palace Job (and its sequel, The Prophecy Con) by Patrick Weekes (I love a good magical heist story), The City of Stairs by Robert Bennet, and Motherless Child by Glen Hirschberg (a reprint, but still a really good vampire novel.)
Well, on my own list (on my blog), the four covers you have on top are four of the 10 books that stuck out for me this year.So we have a fair amount of overlap. Also, The Incorruptibles, Mirror Empire, City of Stairs, Hurricane Fever and The Leopard/The Lady
At the time of writing, I’ve read approximately 230 new-to-me books in the past calendar year.
Now I don’t feel quite so badly that I only managed 351+however many I finish between now and Dec 31 published book reviews this year.
I tried to keep track of all the books I really liked in 2014 but that all fell apart when I began my own site because unlike RT, PW or Bookspan, I appear to have neglected any sort of quanititative rating system.
I can say that I really liked Tolmie’s The Stone Boatmen (which got some really backhanded praise from Le Guin, basically that the book is so good it will remain obscure).
I also liked Emmi Itäranta‘s Memory of Water.
And Church’s Elements, despite this bit in one of the stories:
Merner runs from Cameron to Frederick. Merner is parallel to Lackner and never particularly close to it; the two cannot cross! I am as shocked as you are: she’s clearly set the story in a Kitchener where the road builders of old weren’t just drunks with no access to compasses (apparently) but people who used non-Euclidian geometries when they laid out the streets.
(Note for people not familiar with Kitchener-Waterloo: it’s the sort of place where two parallel roads can intersect three times)
Aside from Leckie’s novels, I really like Jo Walton’s alternate world tale, My Real Children. And I’m still a P.C. Hodgell fan with The Sea of Time in her continuing Kencyrath series.
All of my favorites from 2014 are what I consider fantasy; some are on your list as well: Jo Spurrier’s very dark North Star Guide Me Home; Elizabeth Bear’s celestial Steles of the Sky and her Promethean One-Eyed Jack; Ben Peek’s piquant The Godless; Max Gladstone’s crafty Full Fathom Five; Rjurik Davidson’s new weird Unwrapped Sky; David Edison’s electrifying debut The Waking Engine; Sam Sykes’ psyched-out The City Stained Red; R. S. Belcher’s gasser The Shotgun Arcana; M. L. Brennan’s foxy Tainted Blood; Jaye Wells’s addictive twosome Dirty Magic and Cursed Moon; Den Patrick’s edgy The Boy with the Porcelain Blade; Karen Miller’s crowning achievement The Falcon Throne; Kameron Hurley’s effulgent The Mirror Empire; Mark Smylie’s macabre The Barrow; Elliott James’s charming Daring; Mark Lawrence’s noble Prince of Fools; Jeff Salyards’ gritty Veil of the Deserters; Juliet Marillier’s grim Dreamer’s Pool; Stephen Blackmoore’s duo of go-for-broke novels Broken Souls and Mythbreaker; Django Wexler’s revolutionary The Shadow Throne; Chris Willrich’s smoothly elegant, otherwordly The Silk Map; Lev Grossman’s spellbinding The Magician’s Land; and Sarah Tolmie’s wholly mythic and ageless The Stone Boatmen.
By the way, you mention Roz Kaveney’s Resurrections. I read the first two books in the series, Rituals and Reflections, and although I found the inherent story to be fascinating and cleverly written, there were so many typos that I found them too distracting to be able to enjoy the narrative. It was like reading something that was mostly written by a masterful adult writer who had a third-grade student type randomly placed interludes on virtually every page. Consequently, I haven’t bothered to try the third book.
The most impressive novel I read this year is William Gibson’s “The Peripheral”, which ranks among his five best novels and his best SF one since “Idoru”, simply as an engrossing post-cyberpunk/crime/thriller novel. Coming close too are Michel Faber’s “The Book of Strange New Things”, about an English Protestant Christian missionary to the alien inhabitants of a newly discovered world, while back home, his world is coming apart, and Emmi Itaranta’s “Memory of Water”. I also have to praise Monica Byrne’s “The Girl in the Road”, as quite possibly, the best debut novel published in SF this year. I think the best fantasy novel I read this year is Robert Jackson Bennett’s “City of Stairs”, with notable nods too to Lev Grossman’s “The Magician’s Land” and Richard K. Morgan’s “The Dark Defiles”. I also have to commend Peter F. Hamilton’s latest “Commonwealth” novel, “The Abyss Beyond Dreams”. Probably the best novel I read this year that wasn’t newly published is Lauren Beukes’ “Moxyland”, a terrific homage to early William Gibson and John Shirley.
It says much about the current state of fandom that a lookback on the best writing of 2014 starts with the number of books by women, authors who identify themselves as women, authors who identify themselves as men and men. I suspect next year we’ll see a breakdown of the number of minority authors Liz has read.
Whatever happened to the good old days when people were content to read books and didn’t care if the author was from Mars or from Venus.
On the contrary, I think old school fandom would also have cared a great deal if the author was from Mars, Venus, or a small blue creature from Alpha Centauri. We’d be living in a science fiction future!
(I would like credit for not making the OTHER puerile planetary joke there though.)
@8 mvink
The current state of fandom is this:
Women are published in SF&F at nearly an equal rate as men. The last figures I saw were something like 47-48% genre books published each year are written by women, compared to 53-52% men. Given that women frequently publish using intitals instead of their real, female identifial names, that could be closer.
The current state of fandom, where women are published as often as men, is this:
Women are reviewed far far less then men. They get less “buzz”, less marketing, less promotion, less of everything. Women are nominated for far fewer awards. A “good” end of year list of the ten best books will have one or two women authors listed. Many, if not most, lists have no women at all.
Ever look at which authors of adult SFF are promoted at big comic cons? All men. All of them.
I wonder why that is, given the current state of fandom?
Back in “the good old days”, women sat back meekly and watched their careers die. We aren’t content to do that anymore.
I would have to say:
The Martian, Andy Weir
The Girl With All the Gifts, MR Carey
Magician’s Land, Lev Grossman
Red Rising, Pierce Brown
Station Eleven, Emily Mandel St. John
Rat Queens, Kurtis Wiebe
On Such a Full Sea, Chang-rae Lee
Rogues anthology, George RR Martin
Queen of the Tearling, Erica Johansen
The Goblin Emperor, Katherine Addison
(and if I’d finished The Bone Clocks in time, it would be there too!)